
In a tragic turn of events, the Mahoning County courtroom became a scene of chaos on July 11, 2019, as Dale Williams faced sentencing for the murder of his ex-girlfriend, Elizabeth Pledger-Stewart. This emotionally charged courtroom session took a dramatic turn when Pledger-Stewart’s two sons, Jerome Stewart and Anthony Dees, charged at Williams in a fit of rage. Their attack was reportedly ignited by the intense emotions surrounding their mother’s murder, which Williams had admitted to committing two years earlier.
Williams, 62, had been scheduled to receive his sentence for the heinous act of killing Pledger-Stewart in June 2017. The details of the crime were chilling: Williams had rammed his van into Pledger-Stewart’s car and shot her multiple times as she tried to escape. In the days leading up to the murder, she had filed a police report against him, alleging threats, which underscored the violent nature of their relationship.
As the courtroom proceedings unfolded, the tension in the room was palpable. Pledger-Stewart’s sons were present, grappling with the grief and anger stemming from their mother’s violent death. When the time came for the judge to speak, the courtroom atmosphere shifted. The sons, overwhelmed by their emotions, surged toward Williams, leading to a physical altercation. Witnesses described the scene as chaotic, with deputies quickly intervening to restore order.
In the midst of the melee, law enforcement responded swiftly, using a Taser on one of the sons to subdue him. Both Jerome Stewart and Anthony Dees were subsequently arrested on multiple charges, including assault and contempt of court. This outburst not only disrupted the proceedings but also highlighted the intense emotional trauma that violent crimes can inflict on families.
The courtroom had been on high alert for the potential of such an incident, with extra deputies assigned to ensure security. Mahoning County Sheriff Jerry Greene remarked on the high tensions surrounding the case, emphasizing that the deputies acted appropriately under the circumstances. Despite their efforts, the incident underscored the unresolved grief and rage that many victims’ families experience, especially when faced with the perpetrator in a confined setting.
As the dust settled, the court was left to deal with the repercussions of this emotional confrontation. Williams’ sentencing was postponed, leaving a lingering sense of unfinished business in the courtroom. For the families involved, the path to healing remained fraught with challenges. The courtroom attack became a stark reminder of the pain and chaos that often accompanies acts of violence, reverberating far beyond the immediate incident and impacting families for years to come.
Another similar incident occurred where a 19-year-old White man who killed 10 people in a racist mass shooting at a grocery store in a predominantly Black area of Buffalo, apologised to the victims’ families and was also attacked but was sentenced to life in prison during an emotional court hearing Wednesday.
Leave a Reply